
This just in:
The Supreme Court ruled Thursday that President Bush overstepped his authority in ordering military war crimes trials for Guantanamo Bay detainees.
The ruling, a strong rebuke to the administration and its aggressive anti-terror policies, was written by Justice John Paul Stevens, who said the proposed trials were illegal under U.S. law and international Geneva conventions.
_______________________________________________
This is a WAR.
These people are ISLAMIST TERRORISTS.
These are people who are NOT citizens of the United States.
They are not an Army and they DO NOT represent a NATION.
They do not wear a UNIFORM.
They swear an allegiance to a PHILOSOPHY and perhaps a smattering of religion.
These are people CAPTURED on a BATTLEFIELD in a time of WAR and are being DETAINED.
They are PRISONERS OF WAR.
We must realize: there is no way for an civilized country to conduct a war with another uncivilized country or, moreover, culture and/or philosophy without getting our hands dirty in some fashion.
Otherwise we shall not survive.
The bottom line of this ruling indicates that these people are nothing more than CRIMINALS and therefore they are subject to the same laws as YOU and ME, with all the rights and privileges extant.
Doing The Logical Extension:
Then, does that not mean:
ALL those we capture on the BATTLEFIELD are as a CRIMINAL arrested in any American city.
With all the rights thereto;
And then will not our SOLDIERS be EXPECTED now to ACT and THINK like American POLICEMEN?
And subsequently have to WORRY about being SUED or PROSECUTED in AMERICAN COURTS (and NOT military courts or with the UCMJ applied) as a result of one too many rounds fired, unnecessary wounding, or even “assault with a deadly weapon” for even HAVING BEEN FIRED UPON?
This is absolutely INSANE.
We have taken the first major step to absolutely ENSURE that one or more of the following events WILL occur on sovereign AMERICAN soil:
— The detonation of a dirty bomb;
— The detonation of an actual nuclear device;
— The release of some biological weapon(s);
— The release of some chemical weapon(s);
Not to mention how this will affect our soldiers on foreign soil.
___________________________________________________
The entire culture we are fighting respects but one concept: STRENGTH.
___________________________________________________
We are of sufficient strength and worldly power that the only way to suffer a national defeat is from WITHIN.
And the Islamists KNOW this.
The US Supreme Court has, essentially, sentenced any given number of Americans to DEATH.
I am so disappointed in our country and our system at this moment. I am ashamed.
And frightened for our future.
BZ
___________________________
Additional thoughts an hour later:
Though an incredibly complex decision and I am certain hordes of lawyers are poring over it now, the majority opinion appears to be procedural, thinking that Congress ought to be authorizing military commissions.
Perhaps the next logical step would be to do precisely this.
Absent that, I see nothing more than everyone being simply set free. And that is, on its face, so totally, incredibly wrong.
Will Congress have the mindset to help us triumph and prevail? Knowing, of course, that Congress will be off for the bulk of the summer?
And how much will we have to parse this opinion?